Posts Tagged ‘geni’

David Sacks // It’s the Bread, Not the Peanut Butter

David Sacks, the founder and CEO of Geni, wrote an interesting post for TechCrunch today titled The New Portals: It’s the Bread, Not the Peanut Butter. David writes about the evolution of the "Portal" site and theorizes that Facebook and sites like it, where your social network provides you with relevant information, are the next step in the evolution of the "Portal" site. Interesting theory.

For the last several years, Yahoo, MSN and AOL have all suffered a declining share of pageviews, but that does not mean the portal is going out of style. Rather it has been redefined, first by Google, and now by Facebook in potentially even more profound ways.

Geni Launch Crashes

Yesterday a TechCrunch post pointed me towards a Flash-based family tree creator called Geni. I’m into this kind of thing so I went off to take the new product for a spin. Unfortunately, Geni wasn’t prepared for the traffic that came their way when they were picked up by TechCrunch, Lifehacker, and other sites. Yesterday, I was willing to cut them some slack but they’re still having problems today and I’m loosing patience as I imagine others are. Geni would have been much better off with a limited and more controlled release. This isn’t the right way to do it – you only get so many chances to impress the early adopters and opinion leaders. A release like this leaves people wondering if they should trust you with their data and it will be hard for them to get past the initial bad impression. A lot of web X.0 startups are just a flash in the pan – Geni’s flash is underexposing the picture.

Updated 01/19/07 – still having technical difficulties

Image: Tried to login 01/19/07

Updated 01/21/07: Arrington agrees with my early assessment – TechCrunch Geni Overwhelmed with Early Popularity – notice the last part of the permalink address "/geni-blew-it/." I finally managed to start building my family tree last night using Geni and there’s a lot I like about the service. If they can get past the technical hurdles Geni is sure to be very popular.

Updated 01/22/07: keeps sending me this very generic, not all that informative, automated message. I’ve received 3 exact copies of this message. Suggestion: make it more friendly, informative, and a bit more sincere.

We received an email last week notifying us that the Geni web site had difficulty drawing your tree.  We believe the problem is now resolved.  Thanks for using Geni!


About palmIT

palmIT is authored by Cale Bruckner [LinkedIn], President at Concentric Sky, and former SVP Product Development at Palo Alto Software.

Cale Bruckner

Follow Me on Pinterest

palmIT Facebook Page
@palmIT on Twitter
Cale on Twitter: @calebruckner
Cale on
Cale on Google
Cale on FaceBook
Cale on Flickr
Email Cale @

Concentric Sky